Best Gardening Magazines To Subscribe To: My Honest Reviews
|
|
|
|
One way I get through the winter blues is by reading gardening magazines to get those garden juices flowing, learn new things, and find inspiration. On a blustery winter day, you might find me inside with a hot cup of coffee leafing through a new magazine, my favorite gardening books, or the MIgardener seed catalog, getting excited about the coming spring!
What I don’t want is to pay for a subscription to a gardening magazine, only to find that almost half of the pages are just ads, or that the home decor portion of a home & garden magazine dominates 90% of the content.
If you’re looking to subscribe to a gardening magazine for yourself or to give as a gift for a gardener, but you want an honest review first before you spend your money, you’re in the right place!
Even after I have finished preparing my garden for winter, my passion for gardening doesn’t just fizzle out. It might just have to move indoors and take on a different look, like growing microgreens, house plant care, and garden planning.
If that resonates with you, then I would encourage you to get creative during the wintertime, and keep growing bigger, in every season!

One of my biggest grievances with the home and garden market is that, in the past few decades, quality gardening content in general has substantially declined. Not just on television and in magazines, but also in trade shows and the local scene.
I think gardening is a vastly underappreciated and under-represented portion of the home and garden market. You might go to a home & garden trade show, only to find that the home portion takes up 80-90%, while only 10% is actually garden related.
I find that to be really frustrating, especially as someone who is not all that interested in home decor. This is what sparked the search for the best gardening magazines—the ones that have continued to publish gardening content for us to enjoy.
I do want to preface that I did this review in the middle of November, so many magazines were gearing up for the holiday season. But if you’re like me, I want to learn about gardening all the time!
MIgardener doesn’t switch to producing home decor content during the off-season because we’re a gardening channel. (I don’t really think most of you want to watch, “Luke Decorates His Home for Christmas”.)
If there is a magazine that I’m going to subscribe to, I will be getting regular publications. I don’t want to subscribe to a magazine that is going to change course halfway through the year either.
That being said, I actually think November was the perfect time to find the best gardening magazine because, if they have enough gardening content in them to earn points during the “non-gardening” season, then they are, more than likely, going to have the most gardening content and be the best year-round!

In a quest to find the best gardening magazine, I went out and got my hands on a LOT of gardening magazines! The reason for doing this was so that I could compare them.
I created a rating system that scores each magazine in the different categories that matter most to me as a gardener. These categories are price, page count, pages dedicated to gardening, garden tips, minimal advertising (because who wants to pay for content and get an ad instead?!), and the number of publications you get in a year.
Points were awarded or subtracted as follows:
Price - I took the average price of a single magazine, which is $8. If the cost of a magazine went above $8, I subtracted 5 points. If the cost of the magazine was below $8, I added 5 points.
Pages - The more pages a magazine has, the more interesting it is to thumb through. So I awarded 1 point for every 25 pages.
Ads - Likewise, the more ad pages a magazine has, the more points lost. For every 10 pages of ads, 1 point was deducted.
Gardening Content - Every 1 gardening page added 1 point. I classified everything involving plants as gardening content, all the way from mentioning plants to actual “in the garden” content. (With cooking and recipe pages, the focus had to be on food that came from a garden, and not on the dish itself to receive a point.)
Gardening Tips - 5 points were awarded for each gardening tip given because I think this is the gold standard of what makes a good gardening read!
Number of Publications - 1 point was awarded for every publication you would receive in a year. So monthly publications received 12 points, quarterly publications received 4 points, and so on.
At the end of looking through all these magazines associated with gardening, I do think I discovered the best magazine!

While this is not an exhaustive list of all the gardening magazines out there, I have listed my reviews of some of the well known gardening magazines, the magazines that scored the best, and some others worth mentioning:
Magazine |
# of Points Scored |
My Review |
Better Homes & Gardens |
27 points |
Almost half of the pages were ads, very little of the magazine was actually about gardening |
Northern Gardener |
125 points |
Region-specific with few ads and good garden content |
Magnolia |
11.5 points |
Plenty of inspiration and style, but not much gardening content |
HGTV |
12.4 points |
More focused on selling products than informing or educating and had almost zero gardening related content |
In Her Garden |
167.5 points |
Loads of great gardening information, even for men |
Birds & Blooms |
68 points |
Good for a gardener who is also a bird/nature lover |
Garden Gate |
138.5 points |
Packed with gardening tips & information and fewer ads |

And the winner is In Her Garden magazine with a whopping 167.5 points! In my opinion, this is the best gardening magazine that you can buy and it has everything I look for in a gardening publication.
In Her Garden is a hefty publication that is just packed full of great gardening information! It is made with quality and beautiful color.
The writing was interesting, informative, and very thorough. Despite the name, I would feel totally comfortable recommending it to another guy reader.
The strong second place finisher was Garden Gate, followed by Northern Gardener coming in third. Birds & Blooms gets honorable mention because, although it didn’t score as high because it is a smaller publication, Birds & Blooms may be the perfect choice if your gardener is also a bird lover!